Pirate captains were unlike captains on merchant and naval ships and even on some privateer vessels, who had absolute authority and could act like tyrants without repercussion and who usually came from the privileged class. The amount of authority a pirate captain had could vary from vessel to vessel. Pirates weren’t generally willing to accept too much authority and it would have been difficult to lead a group of individuals who valued their liberty above all else through coercion, although the crew generally accepted they needed a some sort of representative or figurehead. Many mariners had turned to piracy precisely because of the strict discipline and harsh punishments of life on merchant and naval ships.
Pirate Captains were usually elected because they were respected, not feared. They had to possess ability, courage, and charisma, and be willing to lead from the front. They also needed capture enough prizes to keep the crew happy and fed.…